What would happen if four families each contributed one member to create a new family? In this episode of Family Swap, Christie Stevens decides to prank her swap hubby and swap kids by bringing them big bowls of broccoli for breakfast. Since they're doing April Fools pranks, swap siblings Kenzie Reeves and Nathan Bronson decide to do a prank of their own. They know their swap mom Christie takes a nap every day and they suspect that during that time she's fucking their swap dad, Calvin Hardy. Wouldn't it be funny for Calvin to find Kenzie in bed instead of Christie? They tell Calvin that Kenzie and Christie are swapping beds, even though Christie doesn't know anything about it.

Kenzie gets into bed during Christie's normal naptime, and sure enough, Calvin comes on in and spoons behind her. Kenzie decides she likes the way her swap daddy's dick feels so she stays quiet as Calvin starts fucking her tight twat. Eventually Calvin notices and flips out. At the same time, Nathan spies on Christie as she's getting ready to nap. When Christie gets into bed naked, Nathan creeps in behind her and starts getting busy with his bigtit swap mommy. Christie thinks it's Calvin behind her as she grinds her ass against Nathan's hardon. By the time she's gotten into doggy and realizes it's not Calvin, Christie has been really enjoying Nathan's dick inside her. She starts yelling, which brings Calvin and Kenzie in to see what the ruckus is.

When Calvin and Kenzie arrive, Kenzie crawls into bed with Nathan while Calvin pushes Christie onto her knees to give it to her in doggy. That just turns the swap siblings on, so Kenzie mirrors Christie's position with Nathan behind her. Next, Calvin gets on his back so spinner Kenzie can enjoy a bouncing ride while Nathan plows into Christie. The girls swap partners, where Nathan bangs his swap sis until he delivers a nice big cum shot to Scarlet's stomach. Calvin isn't about to be outdone as he gluts Christie with a creampie of his own. Christie and Kenzie happily suck their own pussy juices off the boys' cocks, leaving everyone a smiling and satisfied swap family.